Aston Villa 
4 - 3 - 3
4 - 3 - 31
Emiliano Martínez18
Ashley Young5
Tyrone Mings4
Ezri Konsa2
Matty Cash41
Jacob Ramsey6
88'
Douglas Luiz Soares de Paulo7
John McGinn
21
Anwar El Ghazi20
91'Danny Ings10
86'Emiliano Buendía- 33Carney Chukwuemeka
- 30Kortney Hause
- 14Conor Hourihane
- 16Axel Tuanzebe(88')
- 9Wesley Moraes Ferreira da Silva(91')
- 19Marvelous Nakamba
- 32Jaden Philogene(86')
- 12Jed Steer
- 3Matt Targett
Newcastle United 
5 - 3 - 2
5 - 3 - 227
Freddie Woodman18
78'Federico Fernández6
Jamaal Lascelles5
Fabian Schär11
Matt Ritchie23
Jacob Murphy24
Miguel Almirón
14
46'Isaac Hayden28
90'Joe Willock10
Allan Saint-Maximin9
Callum Wilson- 7Joelinton Cássio Apolinário de Lira(78')
- 2Ciaran Clark
- 21Ryan Fraser(90')
- 34Dwight Gayle
- 29Mark Gillespie
- 16Jeff Hendrick
- 17Emil Krafth
- 12Jamal Lewis
- 36Sean Longstaff(46')