Mainz 05 
3 - 4 - 2 - 1
3 - 4 - 2 - 127
Robin Zentner25
Andreas Hanche-Olsen3
Sepp van den Berg31
Dominik Kohr2
Phillipp Mwene18
Nadiem Amiri
8
Leandro Barreiro19
64'
Anthony Caci
9
56'Karim Onisiwo43
87'Brajan Gruda29
Jonathan Burkardt- 17Ludovic Ajorque(87')
- 23Josuha Guilavogui
- 20Edimilson Fernandes(64')
- 24Merveille Papela
- 10Marco Richter
- 1Lasse Rieß
- 21Danny da Costa
- 44Nelson Weiper
- 30Silvan Widmer(56')
Colonia 
4 - 2 - 3 - 1
4 - 2 - 3 - 11
Marvin Schwäbe35
Max Finkgräfe24
Jeff Chabot4
Timo Hübers2
Benno Schmitz8
72'Denis Huseinbasic6
Eric Martel40
83'Faride Alidou9
62'Luca Waldschmidt29
62'Jan Thielmann21
62'Steffen Tigges- 23Sargis Adamyan(83')
- 18Rasmus Carstensen
- 22Jacob Christensen
- 42Damion Downs(62')
- 3Dominique Heintz
- 11Florian Kainz(72')
- 37Linton Maina(62')
- 20Philipp Pentke
- 13Mark Uth(62')