Mainz 05 
3 - 4 - 2 - 1
3 - 4 - 2 - 127
Robin Zentner19
Moussa Niakhaté42
76'
Alexander Hack4
Jeremiah St. Juste18
Daniel Brosinski20
Edimilson Fernandes6
67'Danny Latza29
76'Jonathan Burkardt5
68'Jean-Paul Boëtius21
Karim Onisiwo9
Jean-Philippe Mateta- 22Issah Abass(76')
- 35Leandro Barreiro
- 37Finn Dahmen
- 11Dong-Won Ji
- 15Luca Kilian
- 14Pierre Kunde(76')
- 3Aarón Martín
- 7Robin Quaison(68')
- 17Kevin Stöger(67')
Colonia 
3 - 1 - 4 - 2
3 - 1 - 4 - 21
Timo Horn23
Jannes Horn33
Sebastiaan Bornauw26
Sava-Arangel Cestic28
Ellyes Skhiri8
82'Ismail Jakobs31
Marius Wolf
20
82'Elvis Rexhbeçaj21
95'Salih Özcan18
Ondrej Duda29
60'Jan Thielmann- 27Anthony Modeste(60')
- 9Sebastian Andersson
- 24Dominick Drexler(82')
- 19Kingsley Ehizibue
- 3Noah Katterbach(82')
- 15Dimitrios Limnios
- 22Jorge Meré
- 2Benno Schmitz(95')
- 16Ron-Robert Zieler