Schalke 04 
3 - 4 - 1 - 2
3 - 4 - 1 - 223
Frederik Rønnow33
Malick Thiaw30
Shkodran Mustafi31
Timo Becker42
Kerim Çalhanoglu
20
78'
Sead Kolasinac8
Suat Serdar13
William de Asevedo Furtado40
46'Can Bozdogan9
93'Benito Raman43
61'Matthew Hoppe- 41Florian Flick
- 17Benjamin Stambouli(46')
- 25Amine Harit
- 34Michael Langer
- 6Omar Mascarell(78')
- 37Levent Mercan
- 24Bastian Oczipka(93')
- 27Luca Schuler(61')
- 28Alessandro Schöpf
Mainz 05 
3 - 5 - 2
3 - 5 - 227
Robin Zentner19
Moussa Niakhaté16
Stefan Bell4
Jeremiah St. Juste23
Phillipp Mwene6
46'Danny Latza31
Dominik Kohr35
89'Leandro Barreiro22
80'Danny da Costa28
74'Ádám Szalai29
89'Jonathan Burkardt- 5Jean-Paul Boëtius(46')
- 18Daniel Brosinski(80')
- 37Finn Dahmen
- 9Robert Glatzel(74')
- 42Alexander Hack
- 14Pierre Kunde
- 7Robin Quaison(89')
- 17Kevin Stöger(89')
- 8Levin Öztunali